I had a hard time enjoying this one... The religious aspects of this book were honestly really annoying. I'm usually fine with books that have religion as one of the themes, but this was just over-kill. Way too much for my little atheist self to enjoy. As a whole, I did enjoy the idea of Kate's faith, and her struggles with God and love. I just wish it had taken over the story a little less. I enjoyed Matt, but I definitely like Sam and Will better in the first two books.